Meshdynamics
Performance Analysis of Three Mesh Networking Architectures
This performance analysis has been partially funded by a United States Air Force (USAF) contract. 
The contract related to specialized deployments of MeshDynamics Structured Mesh Technology in battlefield situations.
 
Abstract.
 MeshDynamics has been talking about multi-radio and multi-frequency mesh since 2002 but there has been confusion about what "multiple-radio" means, and how the MeshDynamics approach is different from others. This paper analyses the relative performance of 3 competing mesh architectures: a single radio ad-hoc architecture, a dual-radio architecture with a single radio ad-hoc mesh, and finally a three-radio MD 4350 product.  
 
We explain why the 3-radio system provides far better bandwidth distribution than other competing architectures. We describe in detail how with merely 5 simultaneous clients per mesh node, both the single radio ad hoc and the dual-radio, single radio mesh architectures cannot provide usable bandwidth (for voice/video) beyond 2 hops and the implications of these limitations. Finally, we describe why a three-radio MeshDynamics architecture is not subject to such limitations. This is what makes Structured Mesh the most efficient means of operating VOIP phones or IP Video over a mesh network or any significant scale.
 
                 
                  Fig. 1: Single radio backhaul and the MeshDynamics 3-radio Structured MeshTM

Background: Before beginning this discussion of mesh architectures, it is useful to define some terms that will be used throughout the paper. Figure 1 shows two types of meshed networks. On the left is the most common configuration with a single backhaul radio and on the right is a MeshDynamics 3-radio MD4350. These types will be described in more detail later, but both have certain similarities. Both must connect, at some point, to a higher speed data network. In most cases this is a wired network, such as an Ethernet network, but this is not necessarily the case. For our purposes, however, we will refer to the high speed data network as the "wired network." At least one node making up the mesh must bridge to that wired network, and we refer to that mesh node as a "root" of the mesh. The mesh network itself is made up of different radio devices, known as nodes. 
 
Radios on the mesh nodes have two functions to fulfill. First, they must provide service to the clients that want access to the services available on the wired network. Second, they must provide a path for information from those clients to the wired network, and vice-versa. The provision of this path to the wired network is referred to as the "backhaul" service. In some cases (the ad hoc mesh network) a single radio provides both services. In other cases (e.g. MeshDynamics) more than one radio is used.

Modern mesh network requirements have evolved from their military origins as mesh networking moved from the battlefield to the service provider, enterprise, and residential networking environments. Today, Internet connectivity is needed more than local peer-to-peer connectivity. Data sources are primarily resident on the Internet, not on a peer. Also, to cover large areas in a cost-effective way, nodes may be placed further away from their eventual connection to the wired network, which implies more relay or "hops" within the mesh until the Ethernet cable (wired network) is reached. 
  

Fig. 2: Competing mesh products suffer from Bandwidth loss with each hop
These new requirements highlight the inherent limitations of conventional, ad-hoc, mesh networks. In an ad-hoc mesh network there is one radio channel on which all nodes communicate with each other. For data to be relayed from mesh node to mesh node it must be repeated in a store-and-forward manner. A node first receives the data and then retransmits it. These operations cannot occur simultaneously because, with only a single radio channel, simultaneous transmission and reception would interfere with each other. This inability to simultaneously transmit and receive is a serious disadvantage of the ad-hoc mesh architecture.

Simply put, if a node cannot send and receive at the same time, it loses ½ of its bandwidth as it attempts to relay packets up and down the wireless backhaul (relay) path. A loss of ½ with each hop implies that after 4 hops, a user would be left with (½*½*½*½) = 1/16 of the bandwidth available at the Ethernet link. This is a 1/(2N) relationship where this equation defines the fraction of the bandwidth that is available to a user after N hops.

There has been much argument on the validity of this 1/2N bandwidth degradation claim. Mesh providers do concede that their products suffer from bandwidth degradation with each hop (Figure 2). But some claim that if the hops between mesh nodes are large enough in distance, there could be simultaneous conversations along a path through the mesh and that bandwidth degradation is closer to 1/N than 1/2N. An independent study indicates a degradation of 1/(1.68)N for typical single radio backhaul topologies. 
 
However, for the sake of this analysis, we shall continue to use the more conservative 1/N scaling factor
 
              
               Fig. 3: competing mesh architectures (L-R): Ad Hoc, 1-Radio Meshed Backhaul, Multi-radio Mesh
 
Comparing Three Mesh Architectures: Three competing mesh architectures are shown above. They are, from left to right:

1. 1-Radio Mesh. As shown on the left, this network uses one radio channel both to service clients and to provide the mesh backhaul. The single mesh radio, marked AH, provides both services - client access and backhaul. The comparative performance analysis to follow indicates this architecture provides the worst services of all the options , as expected- both backhaul and service compete for bandwidth.

2. Dual-Radio with a 1-Radio backhaul mesh. This configuration can also be referred to as a "1+1" network, since each node contains two radios, one to provide service to the clients, and one to create the mesh network for backhaul. The "1+1" appellation indicates that these radios are separate from each other - the radio providing service does not participate in the backhaul, and the radio participating in the backhaul does not provide service to the clients. These two radios can operate in different bands. For example, a 2.4 GHz IEEE 802.11 b/g radio can be used for service and an IEEE 802.11a (5 GHz) radio can be used exclusively for backhaul.

Competing mesh products typically fall into this category. Separating the service from the backhaul improves performance when compared with conventional ad hoc mesh networks. But since a single radio mesh is still servicing the backhaul, packets traveling toward the Internet share bandwidth at each hop along the backhaul path with other interfering mesh backhaul nodes - all-operating on the same channel. This leads to throughput degradations which are not as severe as for the single radio mesh, but which are sizeable nevertheless.

3. 3-Radio MeshDynamics MD 4350  The last architecture shown is one that provides separate backhaul and service functionality and dynamically manages channels of all of the radios so that all radios are on non-interfering channels. Performance analysis indicates that this provides the best performance of any of the methods considered here. Note that the two backhaul radios for the 3-radio configuration shown in Figure 3 are of the same type - not to be confused with 1+1 so-called dual radio meshes where one radio is typically of type A (backhaul) and the other of type B/G (service). In the 3-radio configuration, 2 radios provide up link and down link backhaul functionality, and the other radio provides service to clients.
   
Involuntary Bandwidth Sharing:  Wireless is a shared medium. Radios communicating on the same channel and within range of each other will contend for available bandwidth. How this contention manifests itself differs depending on the radio protocol. In some cases contending nodes may degrade the noise floor, reducing rate, range, or both. In other cases, the nodes may literally prevent each other from using the channel. This is the case with devices based on the IEEE 802.11 suite of standards, which share bandwidth based on collision avoidance rules known as carrier sense multiple access with collision avoidance (CSMA/CA).

Bandwidth reduction - caused from bandwidth sharing - limits backhaul traffic at each hop and is compounded at each hop. If there are C simultaneous clients per mesh node, packets coming from the client at the mesh node farthest from the backhaul have a 1/C bandwidth share as they attempt to reach the closest mesh node.

Aggregated traffic from this node gets a 1/C share again as it attempts to reach the next mesh node. The bandwidth share for the original packet is now 1/2C . This compounding continues: (1/2C.. 1/3C .. 1/4C) until the Ethernet backhaul is reached. Thus, in the case of single 1-Radio mesh with just 2 clients (since the mesh node is effectively another client) the bandwidth degradation per hop follows the 1/NC effect: 1/3 .. 1/9 .. 1/27.

So clients get a piece, of a piece, etc of the total available bandwidth (1/3.. 1/9.. 1/27) .

Thus conventional single radio is useless beyond 2-3 hops for applications requiring either significant bandwidth or low latency. (Latency and bandwidth are inversely related- the thinner the pipe, the longer it takes for data to flow through it).

Analyzing dual radio meshes is more complicated. Dual radio systems have a separate service radio in addition to the backhaul radio that participates in the single radio mesh. Clients attaching to the service radio contend with each to share service radio bandwidth. Data enters the service radio and is transferred over the backhaul mesh through a bridge. When client packets transfer to the backhaul radio, they are subject to contention (involuntary bandwidth sharing) with neighboring mesh radios. Recall that even in these dual radio systems, all backhaul mesh nodes are using the same channel. How many neighboring 1+1 mesh nodes are in contention depends on the mesh topology. In the urban grid model shown (Figure 4), communications must traverse the "Urban Canyons" - tall buildings between blocks. If the nodes are placed at road intersections, then nodes are in range of at least 3 other nodes. At peak times - when all nodes are trying to move packets at the same time - each 1+1 mesh backhaul radio receives 1/4 of available bandwidth - there are a total of 4 nodes involuntarily sharing the same radio medium (recall all the mesh backhaul radios have to be on the same channel). Involuntary bandwidth sharing for the 1+1 mesh in an Urban Grid Topology is 1/4 .. 1/16 .. 1/64 etc. All MeshDynamics nodes  operate on non-interfering channels. Hence it does not suffer from involuntary bandwidth sharing.

                    
                     Fig. 4: Urban Grid Topology - Dual (1+1) Radio Mesh

                    
                     Fig. 5: Urban Grid Topology - MeshDynamics Structured MeshTM

Performance Comparison: We now compare performance for the 3 mesh architectures:

1. First Generation, 1-radio mesh with a single 802.11b radio for Backhaul and client access 
2. Second Gen. : Dual Radio (with 1-Radio Mesh Backhaul): Backhaul 802.11a and 802.11b/g radio for client access. 
3. Third Gen. :MD 4350 3-radio Structured MeshTM with 802.11b/g radio for client access radio and two 802.11a backhaul radios. 
   
                  
 
Hop/Kbps (C=5)
1-Radio Mesh
1+1 "Dual" Radio
MeshDynamics MD4350
Max Backhaul B/W
11000
54000
54000
N=2
152.78
1350.00
5400.00
N=3
16.97
225.00
3600.00
N=4
2.12
42.18
  2700.00
  
A bandwidth analysis of mesh architectures compares the fraction of root node bandwidth available to a client N hops away where there are on average C clients per node demanding access simultaneously. We ignore the effect of bandwidth sharing with some neighboring mesh nodes for the 1-radio architecture (2-dimensional view) since it just makes already bad numbers look worse. In the case of the 1+1 mesh, we assume 4 neighboring nodes as typical for an urban grid. Thus, in an urban grid topology with high client density, the 1+1 mesh will propagate about 1/4 of the bandwidth available at each hop. The bandwidth degradation would then follow 1/4 .. 1/16 .. 1/64 etc. We use the 1/N per hop bandwidth degradation for the 1 radio effect as opposed to the more realistic 1/2N number. Even with 1/N degradation, the results overwhelmingly favor the MeshDynamics 3-Radio MD 4350. 
 
The comparison table above reveals the limitations of an 1-Radio mesh backhaul for wide area coverage. Maximum bandwidth (B/W) that can be supported for the root backhaul is specified for each scenario, thus the results are normalized according to the maximum backhaul capability. Shown in the upper half of the table are the bandwidths available to clients after N hops given C simultaneous clients per node. For the (1+1) scenarios with separate backhaul radios, it is assumed that there are 4 contending neighbors per node in the mesh backhaul. (Diagrams in competitor's literature, show as many as 6-7 neighbors). Even with these concessions, the (1+1) mesh solution with 802.11a (54 Mbps) backhaul provides only 42 Kbps of service to a client 4 hops away from the root. This is not even equivalent to dialup levels! It is barely usable for VoIP - where 64Kbps is desirable. 1-radio backhauls simply cannot scale beyond 2-3 hops. It cannot be used for any type of high resolution video over mesh networks - beyond 1-2 hops. 
   
Summary: Single radio backhauls may work acceptably with light traffic, but bandwidth falls off a cliff when the numbers of simultaneous users and resultant traffic increase. In dense areas with many simultaneous accessing users per node, conventional mesh cannot deliver better than "dialup" bandwidth beyond 3 hops. A large scale mesh network requires many more Ethernet links if the mesh is extended beyond 2-3 hops. Based on bandwidth alone, a multi-radio, multi-channel backhaul is essential for a mesh solution to be useful over wide areas and support a realistic number of simultaneous users. When latency/jitter considerations are brought into play, it is questionable whether high resolution Video over single radio backhauls could be supportable beyond one hop. VOIP comes with its challenges- see VOIP over Wi-Fi Mesh for a more detailed explanation on the latency issues of single radio backhauls and how the MeshDynamics VOIP concatenation engine address them.
  
Web Page MD4000 Products Page. (Overview of our product, Network Management System, Configuration options)
Web Page MD4000 Model Configuration. (Overview of our model configurations and their applications)
Web Page Frequently Asked Questions. (On Antenna selection, GPS, Mobility extensions, Hazard proof enclosures)
 

michael kors outlet jordan 7 for the love of the game marvin the martian 7s teal 4s nike kd vii aunt pearl jordan 7 for the love of the game lebron 12 court vision jordan 5 metallic silver Tom Brady Jersey jordan 4 teal laster 4s New England Patriots Jersey cheap Seahawks Jerseys cheap lady liberty 10s laster 4s Tom Brady Jersey oreo 4s marvin the martian 7s New England Patriots Jersey lebron 12 court vision oreo 4s jordan 3 jordan 7 marvin the martian louis vuitton outlet jordan 4 laster Tom Brady Jersey jordan 7 marvin the martian metallic silver 5s teal 4s oreo 4s teal 4s jordan 10 chicago foamposites red october jordan 7 ftlog jordan 4 laster jordan 7 for the love of the game michael kors chicago 10s jordan 10 lady liberty laster 4s for the love of the game 7s nike kd 7 wings jordan 7 marvin the martian Seahawks Jerseys jordan 4 laster Tom Brady Jersey youth lebron 12 all star jordan 4 oreo foamposites aqua jordan 4 teal lebron 12 all star jordan 4 teal jordan 4 oreo jordan 10 lady liberty jordan 4 laster foamposites mirror jordan 7 for the love of the game jordan 4 laster jordan 7 marvin the martian foamposites metallic gold jordan 3 foamposites mirror jordan 10 lady liberty ftlog 7s jordan 7 marvin the martian foamposites red october foamposites dark obsidian jordan 5 metallic silver nike kd 7 aunt pearl foamposites all star jordan 5 metallic silver jordan 10 chicago teal 4s nike free run michael kors jordan 4 teal oreo 4s teal 4s ftlog 7s for the love of the game 7s foamposites metallic gold chicago 10s metallic silver 5s chicago 10s teal 4s bulls over broadway 10s teal 4s Darrelle Revis Jersey Tom Brady Jersey women's oreo 4s lebron 12 court vision Seahawks Jerseys foamposites aqua jordan 4 laster foamposites red october Tom Brady Jersey women's laster 4s Patriots Jersey louis vuitton outlet foamposites metallic gold chicago 10s Tom Brady Jersey foamposites metallic gold Seahawks Jerseys cheap Seahawks Jerseys cheap jordan 7 ftlog jordan 7 marvin the martian New England Patriots Jersey cheap jordan 4 teal jordan 10 bulls over broadway chicago 10s nike kd vii wings jordan 7 for the love of the game foamposites dark obsidian laster 4s foamposites red october foamposites aqua jordan 4 teal jordan 10 chicago jordan 7 ftlog New England Patriots Jersey jordan 10 chicago jordan 7 marvin the martian foamposites aqua foamposites mirror jordan 10 chicago foamposites metallic gold jordan 10 chicago michael kors outlet teal 4s metallic silver 5s nike kd vii aunt pearl nike kd 7 wings foamposites red october jordan 10 chicago Tom Brady Jersey marvin the martian 7s jordan 7 ftlog Seahawks Jerseys chicago 10s lebron 12 court vision bulls over broadway 10s lebron 12 court vision jordan 5 metallic silver jordan 7 for the love of the game marvin the martian 7s jordan 7 marvin the martian foamposites all star foamposites metallic gold teal 4s jordan 4 laster nike kd 7 wings teal 4s michael kors lady liberty 10s ftlog 7s foamposites metallic gold New England Patriots jersey sale nike kd 7 aunt pearl foamposites aqua New England Patriots Jersey cheap lady liberty 10s lebron 12 court vision jordan 7 marvin the martian michael kors outlet foamposites dark obsidian Seahawks Jerseys cheap jordan 7 ftlog foamposites metallic gold Tom Brady Jersey women's jordan 7 ftlog teal 4s lebron 12 court vision jordan 10 chicago jordan 7 for the love of the game jordan 4 teal metallic silver 5s marvin the martian 7s lebron 12 court vision oreo 4s foamposites metallic gold for the love of the game 7s foamposites aqua marvin the martian 7s marvin the martian 7s foamposites metallic gold New England Patriots Jersey cheap foamposites aqua for the love of the game 7s jordan 4 laster jordan 10 chicago Seahawks Jerseys cheap for the love of the game 7s foamposites red october Tom Brady Jersey foamposites red october foamposites aqua jordan 7 ftlog jordan 7 for the love of the game chicago 10s jordan 10 chicago for the love of the game 7s jordan 7 ftlog New England Patriots jersey sale Tom Brady Jersey Tom Brady Jersey foamposites red october jordan 5 metallic silver louis vuitton outlet teal 4s jordan 5 metallic silver lebron 12 all star foamposites red october ftlog 7s Seahawks Jerseys cheap jordan retro 3 metallic silver 5s lebron 12 all star michael kors outlet New England Patriots jersey sale oreo 4s Seahawks Jerseys ftlog 7s New England Patriots Russell Wilson Jersey foamposites all star foamposites metallic gold ftlog 7s jordan 4 oreo foamposites metallic gold ftlog 7s teal 4s bulls over broadway 10s lady liberty 10s foamposites dark obsidian jordan 10 bulls over broadway Seahawks Jerseys cheap New England Patriots Jersey jordan 4 laster New England Patriots laster 4s metallic silver 5s oreo 4s michael kors outlet Patriots Jersey nike kd vii wings foamposites aqua foamposites metallic gold foamposites metallic gold foamposites metallic gold jordan 7 marvin the martian Russell Wilson Jersey laster 4s louis vuitton outlet jordan 7 ftlog louis vuitton outlet metallic silver 5s foamposites mirror foamposites all star Tom Brady Jersey laster 4s jordan 7 marvin the martian chicago 10s ftlog 7s lebron 12 court vision jordan 4 teal marvin the martian 7s lebron 12 court vision metallic silver 5s New England Patriots Jersey cheap chicago 10s jordan 4 laster marvin the martian 7s jordan 3 jordan 4 laster Tom Brady Jersey metallic silver 5s marvin the martian 7s Seattle Seahawks Jerseys New England Patriots jersey sale foamposites mirror Russell Wilson Jersey Seahawks Jerseys cheap Seahawks Jerseys cheap jordan 7 ftlog New England Patriots Jersey cheap jordan 4 oreo foamposites red october jordan 10 chicago Russell Wilson Jersey jordan 7 marvin the martian foamposites dark obsidian jordan 10 bulls over broadway New England Patriots jersey metallic silver 5s michael kors bags New England Patriots Jersey lebron 12 all star Russell Wilson Jersey youth New England Patriots jersey sale Seahawks Jerseys nike kd vii aunt pearl ftlog 7s foamposites all star jordan 7 for the love of the game jordan 10 chicago Seattle Seahawks chicago 10s louis vuitton outlet oreo 4s ftlog 7s jordan retro 3 teal 4s jordan 7 ftlog lebron 12 all star Seahawks Jerseys cheap louis vuitton outlet Tom Brady Jersey youth New England Patriots Jersey New England Patriots Jersey cheap jordan 5 metallic silver teal 4s jordan 3 chicago 10s metallic silver 5s Seahawks Jerseys jordan 4 teal marvin the martian 7s jordan 7 for the love of the game teal 4s lady liberty 10s jordan 10 chicago ftlog 7s foamposites dark obsidian chicago 10s jordan 7 marvin the martian lebron 12 all star foamposites metallic gold michael kors bags michael kors New England Patriots Jersey cheap chicago 10s oreo 4s nike kd vii wings New England Patriots Jersey nike kd 7 wings jordan 7 for the love of the game jordan 7 for the love of the game jordan 10 lady liberty jordan 7 ftlog Tom Brady Jersey Tom Brady Jersey youth jordan 4 oreo metallic silver 5s jordan 7 marvin the martian chicago 10s ftlog 7s jordan 10 chicago marvin the martian 7s metallic silver 5s michael kors patriots super bowl jersey foamposites all star jordan 4 laster New England Patriots jersey sale metallic silver 5s New England Patriots Jersey nike kd 7 aunt pearl Seahawks Jerseys lebron 12 court vision jordan 3 michael kors bags foamposites red october Russell Wilson Jersey New England Patriots Jersey Russell Wilson Jersey jordan 7 marvin the martian lebron 12 court vision lebron 12 all star nike kd 7 aunt pearl New England Patriots Jersey teal 4s foamposites mirror lebron 12 all star foamposites metallic gold foamposites mirror New England Patriots jersey nike kd vii aunt pearl New England Patriots jersey foamposites metallic gold michael kors Seahawks Jerseys cheap Tom Brady Jersey jordan 4 oreo oreo 4s Russell Wilson Jersey Tom Brady Jersey Tom Brady Jersey Seahawks Jerseys cheap teal 4s Tom Brady Jersey Tom Brady Jersey teal 4s lebron 12 court vision foamposites dark obsidian lebron 12 court vision Seahawks Jerseys cheap louis vuitton outlet Seahawks Jerseys cheap chicago 10s ftlog 7s teal 4s metallic silver 5s laster 4s foamposites aqua marvin the martian 7s lady liberty 10s Patriots Jersey jordan 7 ftlog New England Patriots jersey sale jordan 10 bulls over broadway Patriots Jersey metallic silver 5s jordan 7 for the love of the game foamposites all star Tom Brady Jersey women's jordan 7 for the love of the game jordan 7 marvin the martian foamposites metallic gold foamposites red october jordan 7 ftlog oreo 4s foamposites aqua Tom Brady Jersey marvin the martian 7s foamposites dark obsidian Russell Wilson Jersey jordan 10 bulls over broadway teal 4s jordan 10 bulls over broadway jordan 10 chicago jordan 7 for the love of the game New England Patriots jordan 4 oreo jordan 7 marvin the martian jordan 10 bulls over broadway New England Patriots Jersey cheap jordan 10 chicago marvin the martian 7s Seahawks Jerseys cheap jordan 10 chicago for the love of the game 7s jordan 4 teal jordan 4 oreo foamposites metallic gold marvin the martian 7s laster 4s foamposites metallic gold Tom Brady Jersey lebron 12 all star New England Patriots Jersey patriots super bowl jersey metallic silver 5s foamposites all star jordan 7 ftlog teal 4s jordan 7 ftlog lebron 12 all star jordan 4 laster foamposites metallic gold jordan 7 ftlog teal 4s jordan 4 teal jordan 10 chicago New England Patriots jersey foamposites dark obsidian jordan 10 chicago ftlog 7s new england patriots super bowl jersey metallic silver 5s jordan retro 7 canada goose jordan retro 7 Michael Kors outlet jordan 7 canada goose outlet canada goose outlet beats by dre cheap Michael Kors outlet legend blue 11s coach factory canada goose legend blue 11s jordan retro 7 canada goose outlet legend blue 11s canada goose legend blue 11s legend blue 11s jordan retro 7 moncler jackets moncler jackets coach outlet moncler jackets louis vuitton sac louis vuitton outlet moncler jackets nike free run jordan retro 12 jordan retro 12 jordan retro 12 uggs outlet nike air max beats by dre cheap coach outlet beats by dre cheap nike air max jordan retro 12 jordan retro 12 uggs nike Michael Kors outlet nike canada goose outlet canada goose outlet retro jordans canada goose outlet nike coach outlet retro jordans air jordans Michael Kors outlet legend blue 11s Michael Kors outlet retro jordans Michael Kors outlet canada goose beats by dre cheap Michael Kors outlet jordan retro 7 beats by dre cheap moncler jackets jordan retro 12 nike air max nike air max louis vuitton beats by dre cheap beats by dre cheap nike free run beats by dre cheap louis vuitton sac louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet nike air max jordan retro 12 moncler jackets louis vuitton sac nike free run moncler jackets Michael Kors outlet Michael Kors outlet retro jordans beats by dre cheap jordan retro 7 coach outlet beats by dre cheap beats by dre jordan retro 7 Michael Kors outlet Michael Kors outlet jordan retro 7 coach outlet beats by dre cheap nike canada goose outlet jordan retro 7 jordan retro 7 canada goose jordan retro 7 nike air max nike free run uggs outlet louis vuitton outlet beats by dre cheap louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton coach outlet moncler jackets moncler jackets beats by dre cheap louis vuitton outlet beats by dre cheap louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet jordan retro 12 louis vuitton outlet beats by dre cheap nike air max jordan retro 12 retro jordans jordan retro 7 coach factory jordan 7 beats by dre cheap legend blue 11s Michael Kors outlet Michael Kors outlet jordan 7 coach factory legend blue 11s legend blue 11s canada goose outlet canada goose outlet jordan 7 coach outlet canada goose outlet Michael Kors outlet canada goose outlet nike coach outlet coach outlet nike air max louis vuitton sac coach outlet louis vuitton louis vuitton outlet coach outlet louis vuitton outlet beats by dre cheap louis vuitton outlet nike air max uggs coach outlet coach outlet beats by dre cheap jordan retro 12 jordan retro 12 coach outlet louis vuitton sac jordan retro 7 legend blue 11s Michael Kors outlet canada goose beats by dre cheap nike canada goose outlet jordan retro 7 jordan retro 7 canada goose outlet jordan retro 7 jordan retro 7 canada goose outlet Michael Kors outlet retro jordans Michael Kors outlet legend blue 11s legend blue 11s Michael Kors outlet canada goose outlet moncler jackets beats by dre cheap uggs outlet beats by dre cheap moncler jackets louis vuitton outlet jordan retro 12 louis vuitton outlet beats by dre cheap jordan retro 12 nike air max jordan 12 beats by dre cheap jordan retro 12 uggs jordan retro 12 moncler jackets louis vuitton outlet coach outlet jordan retro 12 Michael Kors outlet canada goose outlet nike coach outlet Michael Kors outlet canada goose outlet retro jordans retro jordans canada goose nike retro jordans canada goose outlet beats by dre cheap canada goose outlet retro jordans Michael Kors outlet legend blue 11s Michael Kors outlet canada goose outlet canada goose outlet moncler jackets nike free run louis vuitton sac jordan retro 12 moncler jackets louis vuitton sac moncler jackets louis vuitton outlet coach outlet uggs outlet moncler jackets louis vuitton louis vuitton outlet nike free run coach outlet louis vuitton outlet jordan retro 12 moncler jackets louis vuitton outlet beats by dre cheap air jordan 4 jordan retro 11 michael kors outlet jordan 11 red cements 10s louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet jordan 11 jordan 4 michael kors outlet jordan retro 13 jordan 4 jordan retro 11 michael kors outlet jordan retro 11 michael kors outlet jordan retro 4 jordan retro 4 jordan retro 11 jordan retro 11 michael kors outlet jordan 11 louis vuitton outlet michael kors outlet jordan 4 red cements 10s legend blue 11s air jordans french blue 7s louis vuitton canada goose sale louis vuitton outlet oreo 4s air jordans uggs outlet michael kors outlet jordan retro 4 jordan retro 11 jordan retro 11 canada goose sale michael kors outlet jordan 4 michael kors outlet louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet air jordan 4 michael kors outlet jordan retro 11 jordan 11 michael kors outlet jordan 11 louis vuitton outlet michael kors outlet jordan 4 retro jordans michael kors outlet jordan retro 11 jordan retro 11 jordan retro 11 louis vuitton outlet jordan 11 jordan retro 4 french blue 7s jordan retro 4 air jordan 4 jordan retro 4 louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet retro jordans michael kors outlet michael kors outlet michael kors outlet jordan 11 jordan 10 red cements michael kors outlet jordan 4 uggs outlet jordan retro 11 air jordan 4 jordan 10 red cements louis vuitton outlet jordan retro 11 jordan retro 11 michael kors outlet jordan retro 11 jordan 10 red cements oreo 4s michael kors outlet oreo 4s louis vuitton outlet jordan retro 4 jordan retro 13 michael kors outlet jordan 11 jordan 4 michael kors outlet louis vuitton outlet jordan retro 11 michael kors outlet michael kors outlet louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet air jordan 4 jordan retro 11 jordan 11 legend blue jordan retro 11 louis vuitton outlet jordan 4 jordan retro 11 jordan 7 french blue jordan retro 11 canada goose sale michael kors outlet jordan retro 11 michael kors outlet michael kors outlet air jordan 4 jordan retro 4 canada goose sale louis vuitton outlet jordan 11 jordan 11 jordan 10 red cements jordan retro 11 louis vuitton outlet jordan 11 jordan 10 red cements jordan retro 4 michael kors outlet jordan retro 11 michael kors outlet louis vuitton outlet french blue 7s louis vuitton outlet jordan 11 louis vuitton jordan retro 4 michael kors outlet jordan 11 uggs outlet jordan 11 michael kors outlet louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet uggs outlet french blue 7s michael kors outlet jordan retro 4 jordan 4 louis vuitton outlet jordan 7 french blue air jordans jordan retro 11 louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet michael kors outlet jordan 4 uggs outlet jordan retro 4 jordan 7 french blue jordan 11 jordan 4 louis vuitton outlet legend blue 11s louis vuitton outlet jordan 11 jordan retro 11 jordan 11 michael kors outlet red cements 10s jordan retro 11 air jordans uggs on sale jordan retro 11 michael kors outlet louis vuitton outlet jordan 11 jordan 4 louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet michael kors outlet louis vuitton outlet michael kors outlet michael kors outlet jordan 7 french blue canada goose sale canada goose outlet louis vuitton outlet legend blue 11s louis vuitton outlet jordan retro 11 legend blue 11s jordan retro 11 uggs outlet louis vuitton outlet michael kors outlet air jordans air jordan 4 legend blue 11s jordan retro 4 air jordan 4 louis vuitton canada goose sale jordan 11 legend blue uggs outlet air jordan 4 oreo 4s air jordan 4 louis vuitton outlet jordan 4 jordan 11 french blue 7s louis vuitton outlet jordan retro 4 michael kors outlet louis vuitton pas cher legend blue 11s canada goose michael kors outlet uggs outlet air jordan 4 air jordans uggs outlet air jordan 4 jordan 10 red cements jordan 11 legend blue michael kors outlet louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton jordan retro 4 french blue 7s michael kors outlet jordan 11 jordan 10 red cements air jordan 4 louis vuitton outlet air jordan 4 michael kors outlet jordan 11 legend blue 11s oreo 4s jordan 11 legend blue jordan retro 4 jordan 11 louis vuitton outlet jordan retro 13 louis vuitton outlet jordan 10 red cements canada goose sale jordan retro 11 louis vuitton outlet jordan retro 11 jordan 4 jordan 11 michael kors outlet michael kors outlet jordan 11 jordan 11 jordan retro 11 michael kors outlet michael kors outlet michael kors outlet michael kors outlet jordan retro 11 jordan retro 4 air jordans air jordans uggs on sale canada goose outlet jordan 11 air jordans retro jordans jordan 13 french blue 7s jordan retro 4 french blue 7s jordan retro 11 jordan 11 jordan 11 louis vuitton outlet red cements 10s air jordans uggs outlet michael kors outlet jordan retro 11 legend blue 11s air jordan 4 louis vuitton outlet michael kors outlet jordan retro 11 air jordan 11 air jordan 4 jordan 4 jordan 11 air jordan 4 jordan retro 4 air jordan 4 jordan 4 louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet jordan 10 red cements michael kors outlet michael kors outlet michael kors outlet jordan retro 11 french blue 7s jordan 11 jordan retro 11 uggs outlet uggs on sale french blue 7s michael kors outlet air jordans air jordan 4 jordan retro 11 french blue 7s canada goose outlet jordan retro 11